The Best Super Bowl Ads of 2011
| Posted in Uncategorized | Posted on 08-02-2011
0
I’m going to try and get back to blogging here a bit more regularly.
Anyway. How about that game last night. As a traitor to the Bears who worshiped Favre as a child and harbored split loyalties between two enemies, I am a bit of a conundrum. I’m a football Rhett Butler. The worst kind of traitor. Hell, I switched loyalties to the Jets and then the Minnesota Vikings over the last few years. That said, who wants to see Pittsburgh win again? No one. How boring is that? Plus, Big Ben may share my name, but he doesn’t deserve it. What a disgrace. i find him more repugnant than Michael Vick.
But let’s take a look at the ads for a second and talk favorites and why I think they were great.
- The VW Passat Ad. This ad was fantastic. Utterly unforgettable. For a generation of kids raised on Star Wars who are all at prime Passat buying ages or just nearing that point, this ad perfectly tapped into Star Wars and childhood nostalgia without getting too cheesy. The first time I watched the ad on the web I thought it was simply a cute little ad. But then I found myself trying to use the force on random objects (at least in my imagination) and humming the Imperial March everywhere I walked the last few days. When I saw the ad again during the Super Bowl I realized why I liked it so much: it made me feel good about Star Wars in a way that I haven’t felt in a long time. In fact, in a way that even George Lucas failed to accomplished with his three prequels. That’s saying something. I have enormous good will towards Star Wars and the halo effect from the emotions stirred up is definitely giving me a sense that VW gets me. Will I remember that it was a Passat ad? I think I will. At least, I feel like VW gets the idea of childhood and the importance of the family car in that important time. The family car is so much more than a vehicle to kids. Its a playground, its a aspiration, its a prison, etc. Fantastic ad.
- Perfectly dissonant, this ad confused me at first. What the hell was this prison? Kenny G? What a perfect way to set up the official differentiation between the “new” luxury and “old” luxury. The ad is especially damning to Mercedes Benz who followed up with a silly ad with P. Diddy. Does anyone care about P. Diddy? That ad following this brilliant Audi ad only reinforced how out of touch Mercedes Benz happens to be at the moment. “My dad drove one.” Ouch. I love the Jason Statham ad Audi ran last year, but this was even more on point and did a better job of differentiating Audi from its competition.
- I’ve heard that there is controversy over this ad. Whatever. As a young guy who is in that prime flower buying period of his life and obviously the target of this ad with Valentine’s day looming, I found it entirely hysterical. The women I was watching the game with were laughing as well. The laughter was pretty explosive in a way that no other commercial except the Doritos “Finger Licker” ad managed to elicit. I loved that Teleflora had the stones to run an ad like this and will think favorably about this online florist for awhile.
- Disclaimer: I really, really, really want a new Camaro. This car is a fantastic surprise from Chevy. My love for the car aside, what a funny ad. Three car ads are in my top favorites. This one took the kind of stupid footage you see in many car commercials of cars driving pointlessly through the desert or jumping off buildings (things you would never do) and added a very funny commentary track. The twist at the end that shows the “hot” girl is really a teacher serves to nicely illustrate that these rough, muscle-y cars aren’t just for juiced up Italian guys auditioning for the Jersey Shore. They’re for anyone. Also, I really like Tim Allen’s voice overs.
- I want to love this ad. I want to hate it. Is is possible for an ad to be one of the best and worst? I think it’s a pretty powerful look at Detroit and a strong narrative is presented as to why American car makers understand luxury despite being headquartered in the ugliest and least luxurious city in America. Then “Lose Yourself” starts playing. Ok, cool. Eminem is from Detroit. Then the Chrysler 200 appears and looks like a less luxurious version of the Chrysler 300. That’s one ugly looking “luxury” car. Ok, personal preference aside, I think the air really went out of the ad when Eminem appeared. Eminem is going to drive this thing? Really? I’m supposed to believe that? Eminem did a great job and if the car was, say, a tricked out Challenger or an Audi A8 then I would have no trouble believing this. I think the authenticity of the ad is a bit suspect. Emienm’s credibility is surely destroyed. There’s no way if asked to pick the car he would endorse he’d pick the Chrysler 200. Kid Rock would. I honestly believe that guy would drive around in the crap that Detroit builds, but Eminem, no way. Still, its resonating with me a few days later and I like what they went for, but I don’t think I’d ever walk into a Chrysler dealer again (and my family has owned nothing but Chrysler cars for 15 years) and it feels a bit disingenuous.
- Let’s talk worst ad for a second. Everyone seems unanimous that the Groupon ad is the loser, but really? Are people really this intensely stupid? Groupon does lose major points for failing to mention that you can donate to the charities and causes being teased on the Groupon website, but these ads were funny. I’m more offended that everyone seems to think Timothy Hutton is some kind of celebrity that everyone should know. Who the heck is Timothy Hutton? Also, did this run during the game? The Groupon ad I saw during the game ran for 5 seconds and didn’t seem to have any content at all. Did my local broadcaster screw it up?




I checked out the workout facilities and found new equipment and treadmills/bikes. All the cardio equipment was equipped with individual TVs that even accept iPod connections. Now, I don’t have an iPod or iPhone due to a longstanding distaste for Apple, but how awesome would it be to plug your iPhone into the machine and watch a movie while working out. Maybe I’ll buy one just for travel. Also, every aloft has a pool. I’m probably a weird business traveler, but I love sneaking in a swim. It makes me feel like a kid. Unfortunately, the pools are usually closed by the time I’m done with meetings. However, the aloft staff told me that the pool was available 24-7. AMAZING! A nice touch for travelers with non-traditional schedules.










